top of page

The U.S.–Israel Alliance Must Evolve

Hazem AlGhabra
1 day ago
6 min read

Why the Heritage Foundation's Controversial Military Aid Proposal Deserves a Second Look


In March 2025, the Heritage Foundation proposed gradually phasing out U.S. military financing grants to Israel. The proposal was quickly treated as a rupture in the U.S.–Israel relationship, even though its central idea was precisely the opposite: a controlled transition from aid recipient to strategic partner. Nearly two years later, as Washington and Jerusalem openly debate the future of American military assistance, Heritage's controversial proposal deserves a fresh, bipartisan look.


On March 3, 2025, I participated in a small roundtable at the Heritage Foundation with representatives of leading Israeli think tanks and Heritage’s Middle East team: Victoria Coates, Rob Greenway and Daniel Flesch. The meeting was to discuss a draft proposal for the future of U.S. security assistance to Israel ahead of its planned release. Given the document’s controversial idea of revising a decades-old aid framework, Heritage was wisely seeking feedback from experts in Israel and the United States.


I thought the proposal’s core concepts made sense. I pressed for a clearer, more technical plan to advance the economic relationship, but supported its central case: the U.S.–Israel alliance should grow into a more robust strategic partnership. The proposal did include an economic agenda: updating the 1985 U.S.–Israel free-trade agreement, pursuing regional trade and energy cooperation, and expanding work in technology. My criticism was that these ideas needed specific milestones, responsibilities and investments. The report was much more precise about the military-financing timetable than about how the economic partnership would actually be expanded.


The public rollout unraveled over the days that followed. The planned Heritage event was set for March 12. On March 11, hours before the report’s release, Jewish Insider published a story headlined that Heritage was calling for an end to U.S. aid to Israel. The story did mention the details of the proposal, but its headline made the eventual end of security grants the defining fact. The crucial distinction between phasing out one form of financing and ending U.S. support for Israel was lost in the ensuing controversy.


The planned event was canceled. The Heritage report was published on March 12, but the narrative behind it had already been lost. It is hard to say whether the article alone caused the lackluster reception that followed, but its timing and framing undoubtedly contributed to derailing the rollout. Before the proposal could be properly presented and debated, it had become a controversy about “ending aid.” The cancellation also meant the report entered public view without the forum intended to explain and test its recommendations. A serious discussion about the future of the U.S.–Israel alliance was overshadowed by a debate over whether America was abandoning Israel.


The U.S. Capitol in Washington, where Congress appropriates military aid to Israel
The U.S. Capitol in Washington. Congress must approve any new military aid arrangement with Israel. (Unsplash)

What the Heritage Foundation Actually Proposed


What did the proposal actually recommend? The existing 2019–2028 memorandum of understanding provides $38 billion in military assistance, subject to congressional appropriations. Heritage proposed starting the next arrangement in 2029 with $4 billion a year in Foreign Military Financing (FMF) grants, plus $500 million for cooperative programs. The grants would decline gradually, reaching zero in 2047. Meanwhile, U.S.–Israeli joint defense programs would grow, and Israel would increasingly purchase U.S. military goods through regular sales. At the endpoint, the report envisioned $2.25 billion in U.S. cooperative-program funding and $2.25 billion in Israeli purchases from U.S. suppliers.


In other words, Heritage was proposing a transition away from FMF grants, not an end to the security relationship. The distinction is fundamental, yet it was largely lost in the initial controversy.


Why U.S. Military Aid to Israel Is Being Reconsidered


Fast forward to recent months, and it is clear that the debate Heritage attempted to initiate is now unavoidable. In September 2026, 55% of respondents in a Marquette Law School national poll said the U.S. was providing too much military aid to Israel; 33% said the amount was about right, and 12% said it was too little. Marquette’s poll shows that skepticism about the current arrangement is no longer confined to a political fringe.


Israeli thinking has also shifted. In January 2026, Benjamin Netanyahu told The Economist he wanted to taper military aid to zero over the next decade, saying Israel had “come of age” and developed significant capabilities. In May, he told CBS, “I want to draw down to zero the American financial support, the financial component of the military cooperation that we have.”


The debate has now moved from theory to policy. On November 3, amid growing political scrutiny of U.S. military assistance to Israel, President Donald Trump announced that the United States would end its roughly $4 billion in annual military assistance by the end of 2026, saying he and Netanyahu had reached an agreement months earlier. However, Netanyahu's office subsequently clarified that the assistance would be phased out gradually rather than terminated immediately. The precise timetable remains unsettled, and the existing aid agreement runs through 2028. Nevertheless, the discussion increasingly resembles the framework Heritage proposed in 2025: reducing direct military financing while maintaining, and potentially expanding, strategic defense cooperation.


That does not mean Israel wants to weaken the alliance. Rather, it reflects a growing recognition that dependence on annual military aid can itself become a political liability, and that greater Israeli independence can coexist with an even stronger strategic partnership.


From Military Assistance to Strategic Partnership


Israel is not the country it was when the aid framework was enacted. As MidEastJournal has previously examined, the history of American military assistance to Israel illustrates how the relationship has evolved alongside Israel's growing military and economic strength.


Israel today is a regional superpower and a global economic powerhouse. Its 2024 GDP was approximately $555 billion, and its high-tech sector accounted for 53% of total exports, according to U.S. and Israeli government sources. The U.S. International Trade Administration and Israel’s National Council for Civilian Research and Development document that economic transformation.


A concrete example of what a more mature defense partnership could look like arrived this year: a Raytheon–Rafael facility in Arkansas delivered the first Tamir interceptor fully built and assembled in the United States. Rather than a one-way transfer of military assistance, this represents the kind of shared production and industrial cooperation that can benefit both countries.


There is also a political imperative to reconsider the current arrangement. The November 3, 2026 midterms demonstrated how easily Israel can become a domestic political cudgel. In Michigan, an outside group’s campaign ad linked U.S. military assistance to Israel with grocery prices. In my view, that was a distortion aimed at political advantage: the $3.8 billion annual commitment equals roughly 0.05% of the federal budget, far too little to make a material difference to grocery costs. The Atlantic’s analysis details the ad and the arithmetic.


The election results had many causes; it would be simplistic to suggest Israel decided them. But the campaign illustrated a growing vulnerability in the relationship: a complex strategic alliance can be reduced to an easy political target, with little regard for the actual figures or the mutual benefits involved.


Building a More Durable U.S.–Israel Alliance


Changing the aid model does not mean downgrading the alliance. It can mean moving from grants toward joint research, co-production, interoperable systems, trade and a durable mutual commitment to security. Such a transition should be gradual, predictable and shaped by both countries, with clear commitments to strengthening the economic and technological relationship alongside defense cooperation.


Let me be clear that my argument is limited to this proposal, not a defense of Heritage as an institution or its recent record on Israel. The Heritage framework offered a serious starting point, even if its economic program needed considerably more substance. What was too easily dismissed in March 2025 now deserves renewed consideration, particularly as Washington and Jerusalem begin discussing the very transition Heritage envisioned.


The opportunity is not simply to reduce American military financing. It is to redefine the relationship around greater Israeli independence, deeper economic integration, joint defense production and shared strategic interests. That requires a more detailed economic roadmap, clear commitments from both governments and potential support from both sides of the aisle in Congress.


The question is no longer whether the U.S.–Israel alliance should evolve, but how to ensure that it emerges stronger, more balanced and more resilient through changing administrations and shifting public opinion.


About the Author


Hazem AlGhabra, born in Damascus, Syria, is the founder and president of Frontiers Consultants, a Washington, D.C.-based consultancy firm that provides public relations and crisis management solutions with a focus on the Middle East and the United States. Prior to starting his firm, AlGhabra held multiple positions with the U.S. Department of State, including senior adviser for public affairs at the Bureau of Near Eastern Affairs. AlGhabra provides regular insight and analysis as a commentator on television networks including i24NEWS, Keshet, Al Arabiya, Sky News, BBC and Asharq Bloomberg.

 
 
bottom of page